Halfway through 18 holes, the beer is warm, your scorecard is already a lie, and nobody wants to talk about that 7 stroke hole you just played. This is exactly when Would You Rather Golf Questions turn a quiet cart ride into screaming arguments that last the rest of the round. Every golfer has yelled over these choices.

They aren’t just silly party games. They reveal exactly what type of golfer someone actually is, way better than any handicap number ever could. Today we’re breaking down how they work, why they hit so hard, and every question you need for your next tee time.

What Exactly Are Would You Rather Golf Questions?

These are forced-choice dilemmas built exclusively for people who spend half their weekends staring at grass. They take every tiny frustration, secret fantasy, and dumb inside joke from the golf course and turn them into impossible choices. Nobody ever picks the same answer twice, and that’s the point.

They blew up for one simple reason: every golfer has thought about every single one of these scenarios alone in their cart. You don’t need to be good at golf to play. You just need to have spent 4 hours outside being mad at a ball. This is the only icebreaker that works equally well for scratch golfers, total newbies, and the guy who only comes for the post round wings.

Location Perfect Time To Ask
Golf Cart After someone hits a ball into the woods
19th Hole Bar Once the first pitcher arrives
Tee Box While waiting for the group ahead
Rain Delay Shelter Immediately after everyone stops complaining

You don’t keep score. You don’t award points. You just argue. That’s the entire game. The best questions don’t have a right answer. They just have an answer that will make everyone else call you a lunatic for the next year.

Casual Golfer Would You Rather Questions

  • Would you rather shoot your personal best but no one sees it, or shoot 10 over but drain a 70 foot putt that the whole clubhouse watches?
  • Would you rather never hit a slice ever again, or never lose another golf ball for the rest of your life?
  • Would you rather play 18 holes with no bug bites, or play 18 holes with zero three putts?
  • Would you rather have every drive go perfectly straight 200 yards, or every drive go 320 yards but half go OB?
  • Would you rather beat your dad once and never beat him again, or lose to him every single round for the next 20 years?
  • Would you rather finish an entire round without swearing, or finish an entire round under par?
  • Would you rather always hit perfect chip shots, or always make every 3 foot putt?
  • Would you rather play 18 holes in perfect weather alone, or play 18 holes in light rain with your best golf buddy?
  • Would you rather get a hole in one on a par 3, or eagle a par 5?
  • Would you rather have nobody laugh at your bad shot, or have everyone cheer for your good shot?
  • Would you rather carry your bag for 18 holes every time, or always ride in a slow cart behind the worst group on the course?
  • Would you rather know exactly what you do wrong on every shot, or never feel frustrated at golf ever again?
  • Would you rather play a world famous course alone, or play your local muni with your regular group?
  • Would you rather break 90 and lose $20 to your friend, or shoot 105 and win $5 off him?
  • Would you rather have infinite free golf balls, or infinite free cold beer on the course?

Controversial Hot Take Golf Would You Rather Questions

  • Would you rather move your ball 6 inches when no one is looking, or take a 2 stroke penalty that makes you lose the round?
  • Would you rather tell a group they’re playing too slow, or follow them for 9 holes quietly seething?
  • Would you rather give a stranger a good golf tip, or watch them hit 12 balls into the pond and laugh?
  • Would you rather have your golf group always show up 20 minutes late, or always talk during your backswing?
  • Would you rather ban all music on the course, or ban all cell phones on the course?
  • Would you rather play with someone who cheats every hole, or play with someone who complains every single shot?
  • Would you rather fix every divot you make, or make every putt inside 10 feet for a year?
  • Would you rather hit a great shot that bounces into the water, or hit a terrible shot that bounces onto the green?
  • Would you rather never be allowed to use a golf cart ever again, or never be allowed to take a mulligan ever again?
  • Would you rather post your real score every time, or never post any score ever again?
  • Would you rather play with a beginner who tries really hard, or play with a scratch golfer who acts like a jerk?
  • Would you rather give away all your good golf clubs, or give away all your good golf buddies?
  • Would you rather the course be 100% dry and rock hard, or 100% soft and soaking wet?
  • Would you rather call a penalty on yourself that nobody saw, or win the club championship by one stroke?
  • Would you rather never get a hole in one, or get a hole in one that makes you buy everyone drinks all night?

Rain Delay & Boredom Golf Would You Rather Questions

  • Would you rather sit through a 3 hour rain delay, or play 18 holes in steady light rain?
  • Would you rather wait 15 minutes on every tee box, or never get to stop for a snack the whole round?
  • Would you rather have the marshal yell at you once, or have the group ahead stare at you every hole?
  • Would you rather watch old golf highlights for 2 hours, or listen to your friend’s swing theory for 2 hours?
  • Would you rather play through a swarm of gnats, or play through 10mph wind the whole round?
  • Would you rather drop your phone in a pond, or drop your favourite putter in a pond?
  • Would you rather forget your golf gloves, or forget all your beer for the round?
  • Would you rather hit into the group ahead once, or get hit into by the group behind 3 times?
  • Would you rather walk past the same alligator every hole, or have geese chase you once per 9 holes?
  • Would you rather break your driver on the first hole, or break your putter on the 17th hole?
  • Would you rather run out of golf balls on hole 16, or run out of water on hole 4?
  • Would you rather have your hat blow off mid swing, or have your pants rip while bending for a ball?
  • Would you rather tee off at 6am freezing, or tee off at 2pm 95 degree heat?
  • Would you rather lose your scorecard half way, or lose your car keys after the round?
  • Would you rather stay dry the whole round but lose, or get completely soaked and shoot your best score?

Absurd Fantasy Golf Would You Rather Questions

  • Would you rather be able to talk to your golf ball for 10 seconds before every shot, or be able to re-do one shot per round?
  • Would you rather play 18 holes with Tiger Woods at his peak, or play 18 holes drunk with your favourite comedian?
  • Would you rather every putt you look at goes 1 inch left, or every putt you look at goes 1 inch short?
  • Would you rather make a living as a tour pro that never wins, or win one major championship and never play good golf again?
  • Would you rather have a caddy that always tells you the truth, or a caddy that always tells you that you’re doing great?
  • Would you rather golf on the moon with normal gravity, or golf on the beach with perfect grass?
  • Would you rather never miss a 6 foot putt ever, or hit one drive over 400 yards once in your life?
  • Would you rather have all your golf shots make a silly cartoon noise, or everyone claps very slowly after every shot you hit?
  • Would you rather know the exact day you will shoot par, or never know how good you could actually get?
  • Would you rather play every round with perfect weather alone, or play every round with your friends in whatever weather?
  • Would you rather turn every bad shot into a good one, or never feel bad about any bad shot ever again?
  • Would you rather have your dog be your caddy forever, or have a top 10 pro caddy for you once?
  • Would you rather win the masters but everyone forgets after 1 year, or have the best hole in one story that your friends tell forever?
  • Would you rather never lose a golf ball again, or never have to search for a golf ball ever again?
  • Would you rather have golf be the only sport you can play forever, or never be allowed to play golf ever again?

19th Hole Bar Golf Would You Rather Questions

  • Would you rather buy the first round and win the round, or get bought drinks all night and lose the round?
  • Would you rather lie about your score by 3 strokes, or admit you shot 12 over?
  • Would you rather rehash your good shots for 2 hours, or make fun of your friend’s bad shot for 2 hours?
  • Would you rather everyone forgets your worst shot, or everyone remembers your best shot?
  • Would you rather eat bad hot dogs at the course, or go get nice burgers after the round?
  • Would you rather play another 9 right now, or sit and drink for 3 hours?
  • Would you rather bet $1 on the next 3 putt, or bet $100 on the first coin flip?
  • Would you rather your friend never brings up that you choked 18, or you never have to hear about his hole in one again?
  • Would you rather leave your clubs in the parking lot overnight, or leave your wallet at the bar?
  • Would you rather watch the tour championship with your group, or go hit range balls for an hour?
  • Would you rather plan the next weeks tee time right now, or never talk about golf for the rest of the night?
  • Would you rather give your best club to your friend, or buy him a whole case of beer?
  • Would you rather admit you don’t know any rule, or make up a fake rule and everyone believes you?
  • Would you rather tip the cart girl really well, or save that money for extra beer?
  • Would you rather drive home tired but happy, or crash on the couch at the course and play again tomorrow?

Frequently Asked Questions about Would You Rather Golf Questions

When should I start asking these questions?

Wait until you finish the 3rd hole. Nobody is in a good enough mood before that. Never ask right before someone is about to hit their shot.

Is there a correct answer to any of these questions?

No. That is the entire point. If someone says there is a correct answer, they are wrong and you should argue with them for at least 7 minutes.

Can I make up my own Would You Rather Golf Questions?

Absolutely. The best ones are made up on the cart ride about something that just happened on the last hole. Add inside jokes for extra chaos.

Are these appropriate for junior golfers?

Most are fine. Just skip the beer and betting questions. Kids will argue twice as hard about golf balls and slices anyway.

Why do people get so mad about these questions?

These questions force people to admit what they actually care about on the course. Most golfers lie to themselves about this every single round.

How many questions should I ask per round?

10-15 is perfect. Any more and people will stop talking to you. Space them out between bad shots.

Do pro golfers play this game?

Yes. Multiple tour players have admitted they argue about these exact questions on cart rides during practice rounds.

What if everyone picks the same answer?

Throw that question out. Immediately ask a different one. Good questions split the group exactly 50/50.

At the end of the day, none of these choices actually matter. That’s what makes them so good. Golf isn’t really about the score on the card. It’s about the stupid arguments you have with your friends while you chase a little white ball around for four hours.

Would You Rather Golf Questions don’t just pass the time. They turn a regular round of golf into something you’ll laugh about six months later. Next time you’re waiting on the tee box, pull out this list, ask one question, then sit back and watch the chaos unfold.